Fake DR

RPDRAS1
Other queens considered for the first edition of All Stars included RPDR2 contestant Alyssa Edwards, RPDR1 contestant Gigi Goode, RPDR2 contestant/RPDR4 runner-up Jaymes Mansfield and RPDR3 contestant Plastique Tiara. In addition, RPDR3 contestant Dax! was initially cast for the season, but was dropped in favor of queens who had placed higher in their original seasons. This was around the time Kimora Blac and Shannel were added to the final roster.

All Stars 1 was the first to utilize the "Lip Sync For Your Legacy" format in which a cycle's two top-performing queens would face off in a lip sync battle for a $10,000 prize and the right to eliminate a bottom queen of their choice.

During the first episode, queens competed in pairs. The top two pairs (four queens total) lip synced against each other for the power to eliminate one of the bottom queens. Each top queen choice one queen from each bottom pair to be eliminated, ranking them by elimination preference.

During the sixth episode, each of the six remaining All Stars paired up with an eliminated queen. It was then revealed that the top two teams would win the consequent challenge with the winning eliminated queens partaking in the lip sync. The winning queen would receive $10,000, eliminate a bottom queen of their choice and return to the competition.

RPDRAS2
Other queens considered for the second edition of All Stars included RPDR3 contestant Dax! and RPDR1 contestant/RPDR7 runner-up Mrs. Kasha Davis. Both were initially cast for the season before later being dropped for RPDR2 contestant Alyssa Edwards and All Stars 1 contestant A'keria C. Davenport, respectively. All Stars 1 contestant Dusty Ray Bottoms was slated to compete during the season before a medical issue forced her to withdraw; All Stars 1 runner-up Monique Heart was cast in her place.

All Stars 2 was the second to utilize the "Lip Sync For Your Legacy" format in which a cycle's two top-performing queens would face off in a lip sync battle for a $10,000 prize and the right to eliminate a bottom queen of their choice.

During the first episode, queens competed in pairs. The top two pairs lip synced against each other for the power to eliminate one of the bottom pairs.

During the sixth episode, each of the six remaining All Stars paired up with an eliminated queen. It was then revealed that the top two teams would win the consequent challenge with the winning eliminated queens partaking in the lip sync. The winning queen would receive $10,000, eliminate a bottom queen of their choice and return to the competition.

Contestant progress
AS
 * SAFE
 * style="background:royalblue;"| WIN
 * style="background:#D4AF37;"|Winner
 * style="background:tomato;"|BTM2
 * style="background:red;"|ELIM
 * style="background:cornsilk;"|SAFE
 * style="background:lightpink;"|LOW
 * style="background:lightblue;"|HIGH
 * style="background:silver;"|Runner-up
 * style="background:sienna;"|Eliminated
 * style="background:yellow;"|WIN
 * style="background:cornflowerblue;"|WIN
 * style="background:navy;" | WIN
 * style="background:purple;" | OUT